I'm not knocking the reels on the list you've got, but I voted for 'Other' being the Orvis Battenkill disc drag reel. This is allegedly the most popular fly reel saleswise worldwide. the '3/4' is 4 oz, 2.7/8'' diameter, exposed rim with a proper drag for 2/5 wt lines. They retail for about sixty quid so in your price range. They are hugely reliable. The beauty with this reel, is that it can be used on the streams and double up as a dam trout or yellowfish reel using heavier line. I have had the range of Orvis CFO (slightly pricier) reels for yonks and never had one malfunction in the slightest.
++
As an aside:
If you can get your hands on an old Ryobi Magnesium 255 or 355 on auction off the web and it's in good nick (excuse the pun) they're great for small-stream fishing - ultralight and great value, but a tendency to 'dent' as the magnesium's a bit soft. I still have my functional 255 which I use as a back-up for my 1,2 and 3 wt rods.
Bookmarks